Each song is evaluated against the Worship Theology Grid — a framework for assessing whether a congregational worship song is biblically grounded, doctrinally clear, Christ-centered, and pastorally useful.
Scriptural Grounding
Does the song draw clearly from Scripture — its language, themes, storylines, promises, commands, or vision of God?
Can I identify biblical themes or passages? Does it use biblical imagery faithfully? Would it help people remember or inhabit Scripture?
Doctrinal Clarity
Does the song clearly communicate Christian truth about God, Christ, salvation, grace, sin, resurrection, the Spirit, the church, or hope?
What doctrine does it teach? Is the meaning clear without a long explanation? Could the main idea be misunderstood?
God-Centeredness
Where is the center of gravity: God’s character and works, or mainly my experience of God?
Is the main focus God or my feelings? Does it spend more time on God’s action or my response?
Gospel Presence
Does the song clearly connect worship to the good news of Jesus Christ?
Does it name Jesus? Does it point to the cross, resurrection, grace, forgiveness, redemption, or hope?
Clarity vs. Ambiguity
Is the song clear enough for the congregation to sing without confusion?
What is the main claim? Could a church member explain it? Do I need to explain away confusing lines?
Congregational Usefulness
Can ordinary people sing this well and meaningfully in gathered worship?
Is the melody singable? Does it work corporately? Where would it fit in the service?
Pastoral Durability
Will this song serve the church well over time and across seasons?
Can someone suffering sing it honestly? Does it make room for waiting, weakness, repentance, or unanswered prayer?
SCORE PER CATEGORY
5Strong / clear / highly useful
4Solid / usable with minimal concern
3Mixed / usable with context
2Weak / needs significant framing
1Poor fit / not recommended
TOTAL SCORE OUT OF 35
30 – 35Strong · Use freely
24 – 29Good · Use thoughtfully
18 – 23Use with caution
Below 18Probably avoid